1725 Hopley Avenue
P.O. Box 111
OH 44820
(800) 686-3011

Ohio Mutual Insurance Group (OMIG) traces its roots to 1901, when the Ohio Mutual Tornado, Cyclone and Windstorm Insurance Association began providing insurance to property owners across Ohio.

Today, with more than a century of successful history behind us, we retain the small-town location and values upon which we were founded, while offering a broad array of industry-leading products and cutting-edge technology that positions us to be a leader in the property and casualty insurance industry for many years to come. While our location and values have remained consistent over our past century in business, we now offer a full-line of personal and commercial insurance products that are marketed through a network of carefully-selected independent insurance agent partners. The 2010 acquisition of Maine-based Casco Indemnity and establishment of a New England Regional Office has added additional capacity for growth and diversification.

Based in Bucyrus, Ohio, OMIG writes more than $195 million in premiums each year — covering homes, autos, farms, and commercial properties in seven states. We maintain the prestigious “A” Excellent rating from A.M. Best, and were named in 2009–2013 among the top 50 insurers in the country by Ward Group — recognizing our outstanding operating performance, capitalization, underwriting expertise, and prudent investment strategy.

In addition, the nation’s largest association of independent insurance agents in 2009 honored Ohio Mutual as its company of the year, awarding it the coveted National Company Award of Excellence. Independent agents in Ohio have rated us for the past three years among the top three companies in the state with which to do business. These ratings and awards reflect the efforts of our agent partners, more than 220 dedicated associates, and a stable, experienced, and forward-thinking management team. Our financial performance is among the best in the country — consistently outperforming many of our competitors in the property and casualty insurance industry.

The company recognizes the value of leveraging technology to maintain its leading position in the marketplace. Our award-winning e-Quip'd® agency interface tool allows our agent partners to accurately quote business in their offices and to print the policy while the customer is present. Our next generation of technological innovation features the introduction of our industry-leading 360access® tool that allows policyholders 24/7 access to their policy information. This kind of technology enables us to maintain a competitive edge within our industry, and to maintain the personalized service and relationships that our policyholders appreciate.

Ohio Mutual Insurance Group is an organization that is deeply anchored in its history and traditional core values, while embracing the tactics and tools necessary to successfully advance into a dynamic and profitable future.

Partner Type